How We Test Open Wireless Earbuds: A Comprehensive Guide

Introduction

When it comes to selecting the best open wireless earbuds, the process is not just about picking the most popular or the most expensive option. At CNET, we take a meticulous approach to testing these devices, ensuring that every aspect of their performance is thoroughly evaluated. Our testing methodology is based on five key criteria: design, sound quality, features, voice-calling performance, and value. These criteria help us determine how well a pair of earbuds stacks up against its competitors and whether they are worth the investment. In this guide, we’ll break down each criterion in detail, explaining how we test open wireless earbuds and what factors matter most to us.

Design: Comfort, Build Quality, and Usability

The first thing we consider when evaluating open wireless earbuds is their design. This encompasses not just how they look but also how they feel and function. Comfort is paramount. We assess the ergonomics of the earbuds, paying attention to how well they fit in the ear and whether they remain comfortable over extended periods of use. We test them on different ear shapes and sizes to ensure they are universally comfortable.

Build quality is another critical aspect. We examine the materials used, whether they feel premium or cheap, and how durable they seem. A pair of earbuds that feels flimsy or cheap is unlikely to last long, no matter how good they sound. We also look at the controls—whether they are intuitive and easy to use. Are the touch controls responsive? Are the buttons easy to press without causing discomfort? These are all important factors in our design assessment. Additionally, we consider water- and dust-resistance ratings, as these can significantly impact the longevity of the earbuds, especially for users who plan to use them during workouts or in harsh environments.

Sound Quality: The Heart of the Listening Experience

Sound quality is, of course, a cornerstone of our testing process. We believe that no matter how good the design or features, if the earbuds don’t sound great, they aren’t worth your money. To evaluate sound quality, we use a carefully curated playlist of music tracks that highlight different sonic traits. We listen to everything from deep basslines to intricate high-frequency details, ensuring that the earbuds can handle a wide range of musical genres with clarity and precision.

We also compare the earbuds to top competing models in their price range. This helps us determine whether they offer superior or merely average performance for their class. Key factors we consider include bass definition, clarity, dynamic range, and how natural the sound feels. We want to know if the earbuds can deliver an immersive listening experience or if they fall short in any area. Our goal is to ensure that the earbuds we recommend sound as good as—or better than—any other option available at their price point.

Features: Beyond the Basics

Not all great-sounding earbuds are packed with features, but we still consider what extra functionalities they offer. Features can greatly enhance the user experience, and in some cases, they can make or break a purchase decision. One of the key features we look for is noise-canceling and transparency (or ambient sound) modes. While not all open wireless earbuds offer these features, we evaluate how well they perform when they do. We also consider special sound modes, such as EQ settings or pre-set profiles, that allow users to customize their listening experience.

Another important feature is ear-detection sensors, which automatically pause or play music when the earbuds are removed or inserted. This is a small but convenient feature that can greatly enhance the overall usability of the earbuds. We also look at other features like voice assistant integration, app support, and battery life. While some of these features may not be deal-breakers for everyone, they can make a significant difference in daily use. By considering the full range of features, we can provide a more complete picture of what the earbuds have to offer.

Voice-Calling Performance: Clear Communication in Any Environment

Voice-calling performance is another critical aspect of our testing process. While many people primarily use their earbuds for listening to music, they are also an essential tool for taking calls. We test the earbuds’ voice-calling performance in real-world scenarios, such as the noisy streets of New York. Our reviewer, David Carnoy, has spent countless hours testing earbuds in these challenging conditions, ensuring that they can deliver clear audio even in the most demanding environments.

When evaluating voice-calling performance, we focus on two main factors: how well the earbuds reduce background noise and how clearly callers can hear your voice. We want to know if the microphones can pick up your voice clearly, even in windy or noisy conditions, and if the earbuds can effectively block out ambient noise to ensure that your calls are uninterrupted. We also consider the overall call quality, including whether there is any distortion or lag. By testing in real-world conditions, we can provide a more accurate assessment of how the earbuds will perform in everyday use.

Value: Balancing Performance and Price

Finally, we consider value. This is where we take a step back and assess how well the earbuds perform across all of the criteria we’ve discussed, relative to their price. We believe that value is about more than just the sticker price—it’s about what the earbuds deliver compared to other models in their class. We compare the earbuds to their competitors, considering their design, sound quality, features, and voice-calling performance, to determine whether they offer a good return on investment.

We also consider the overall user experience—whether the earbuds are easy to use, whether they come with useful accessories, and whether they are supported by good software and customer service. By evaluating all of these factors, we can determine whether the earbuds are a worthwhile purchase or if there are better options available. Our goal is to help readers make informed decisions by providing a clear and balanced assessment of the earbuds’ value.

Conclusion

Testing open wireless earbuds is a comprehensive process that involves evaluating every aspect of their design, sound quality, features, voice-calling performance, and value. At CNET, we take pride in our rigorous testing methodology, ensuring that we provide our readers with accurate and reliable information. By carefully assessing each criterion, we can help you find the best earbuds for your needs and budget. Whether you’re looking for great sound quality, convenient features, or reliable voice-calling performance, our tests are designed to give you the insights you need to make the right choice.