Oscars 2025: The In Memoriam Segment Sparks Outrage Over Omissions

Introduction

The 97th Academy Awards, held on March 10, 2025, at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood, California, was a night of celebration and reflection, but it also sparked controversy. One of the most talked-about moments of the ceremony was the In Memoriam segment, which honors actors, filmmakers, and industry professionals who passed away over the past year. Presented by the iconic Morgan Freeman, the segment paid tribute to several legends, including Gene Hackman, James Earl Jones, David Lynch, and Maggie Smith. However, the exclusion of certain notable celebrities, such as Michelle Trachtenberg, Shannen Doherty, and Tony Todd, has caused a stir online, with fans expressing their disappointment and frustration on social media platforms.

The In Memoriam Segment: A Tradition of Remembrance

The In Memoriam segment has long been a poignant part of the Oscars ceremony, serving as a moment to reflect on the lives and contributions of those who left an indelible mark on the film industry. This year’s tribute was no exception, with a moving montage of clips and images of the late stars, accompanied by a heartfelt narration by Morgan Freeman. The segment honored a range of talent, from the incomparable Gene Hackman, known for his iconic roles in films like The French Connection and Unforgiven, to the incomparable James Earl Jones, whose resonate voice is instantly recognizable as Darth Vader in the Star Wars franchise.

However, despite the many legends included in the tribute, the absence of certain names left many viewers feeling perplexed and even angered. Fans took to social media to voice their disappointment, calling out the Academy for the omissions. The exclusion of Michelle Trachtenberg, Shannen Doherty, and Tony Todd was particularly notable, with many questioning why these beloved actors were not included in the tribute.

Social Media Reacts to the Omissions

The backlash against the Academy for the In Memoriam omissions was swift and intense. On X (formerly known as Twitter), the platform was flooded with messages from fans expressing their shock and disappointment. A viral post by user @horrorsthetics summed up the sentiment of many: "NO michelle trachtenberg??? NO shannen Doherty ??? NO Tony Todd???? i’m SICK #Oscars2025." At the time of publication, the post had garnered over 900,000 views and more than 52,000 likes, indicating the widespread outrage over the exclusions.

The reaction to the omissions was not limited to just fans; many in the entertainment industry also weighed in on the matter. The discussion has sparked a broader conversation about the criteria used by the Academy to select who is included in the In Memoriam segment. While some have speculated that the omissions may have been due to oversight or time constraints, others have criticized the Academy for what they perceive as a lack of appreciation for certain actors’ contributions.

The Academy’s Response to the Controversy

In response to the backlash, the Academy has yet to issue an official statement regarding the In Memoriam omissions. However, it is important to note that the selection process for the segment is often a complex and difficult task. Every year, the Academy faces the challenge of honoring as many deserving individuals as possible within the constraints of the ceremony’s runtime. Historically, the In Memoriam segment has been designed to recognize individuals who made significant contributions to the film industry, particularly those who were members of the Academy or worked on films that were highly impactful.

Despite this, the exclusion of Michelle Trachtenberg, Shannen Doherty, and Tony Todd has raised questions about the criteria used to determine who is included. Michelle Trachtenberg, best known for her roles in Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Gossip Girl, has a dedicated fanbase that was quick to express their disappointment. Similarly, Shannen Doherty, known for her iconic roles in Beverly Hills, 90210 and Charmed, has been a beloved figure in popular culture for decades. Tony Todd, known for his chilling performances in horror films like Candyman and Final Destination, has built a loyal following over his long career.

The Broader Impact of the In Memoriam Segment

The controversy surrounding this year’s In Memoriam segment highlights the delicate balance the Academy must strike in honoring the deceased. While the segment is intended to be a celebration of the lives and contributions of those who have passed, the omissions often lead to frustration and disappointment among fans and industry professionals alike. For many, the In Memoriam segment is not just a moment of reflection but also a recognition of the impact that these individuals had on the industry and their audiences.

As the entertainment industry continues to evolve, so too will the expectations surrounding events like the Oscars. The growing influence of social media has amplified the voices of fans, who now have a platform to express their opinions and hold the Academy accountable. This year’s backlash serves as a reminder that the In Memoriam segment is more than just a tradition—it is a representation of the collective memory and appreciation of the film community.

Looking Ahead: The Future of the In Memoriam Segment

Given the reaction to this year’s In Memoriam segment, it is likely that the Academy will face renewed scrutiny in the future. The question of how to create a more inclusive and comprehensive tribute to the departed is one that the Academy will need to address moving forward. One possible solution could involve expanding the segment or creating additional platforms to honor those who have passed, ensuring that no one is left behind.

Ultimately, the In Memoriam segment is a reminder of the ever-changing nature of the entertainment industry and the enduring legacy of those who have made it what it is today. While this year’s controversy has sparked disagreement, it also serves as an opportunity for the Academy to reflect and improve. As the Oscars continue to evolve, so too will the way in which they honor the lives and contributions of the departed.