Alex Verdugo’s PuzzlingUnsigned Status in MLB Free Agency

Youth in a Market Dominated by Veterans

In the 2024 MLB free agency landscape, 62 unsigned players share a common thread—age. Many of these players are in their mid-30s or older, which may explain their struggle to find new teams. However, one name stands out: Alex Verdugo, a 28-and-a-half-year-old outfielder, remains unsigned despite being in his prime.

A Career Marked by Untapped Potential

Verdugo, once lauded as the Los Angeles Dodgers’ top prospect in 2019, has had a career marked by mediocrity, with a .742 OPS, slightly above average. His inability to exceed expectations may lead teams to view him as a middling player rather than a star. His strikeouts in crucial moments, like ending the 2024 World Series, might have tarnished his reputation.

Behavioral Concerns and Team Chemistry

Behavioral issues, such as lack of hustle and tardiness, have overshadowed Verdugo’s abilities. In 2023, Boston Red Sox manager Alex Cora benched him twice, citing unprofessional conduct. While New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone defended his tendencies, such incidents raise concerns about his commitment, potentially deterring teams wary of disruptive influences.

The Role of Personality in Team dynamics

Ken Rosenthal suggests that Verdugo’s "different" personality may be a barrier. Despite being liked by teammates, his quirks might rub clubs the wrong way, impacting his marketability. Team chemistry is crucial, and perceptions of him as difficult could override his on-field utility.

Near Misses and Market Realities

The Pittsburgh Pirates floated an $8 million offer, which they later withdrew after signing Tommy Pham. This lowball offer reflects Verdugo’s market value, suggesting teams see him as a fallback rather than a priority. He may be holding out for a better deal, but in a market favoring younger, cheaper talent, his options are limited.

The Future for Verdugo

Verdugo’s situation highlights the complexities of MLB free agency, where performance, behavior, and perception intertwine. Teams may await a lower asking price or seek a player with higher upside. Verdugo’s next steps will depend on his willingness to adapt and demonstrate both skill and professionalism.